by Scott VanderPloeg

September 25th 2001

When I originally conceived of this article, I planned for two classes of server; a budget machine of $1500 and something decent for $3000. After researching the manufacturer’s web sites and comparing packages, it became apparent that an entry model in either price range made too many concessions. Hence the focus of a good all around machine for $3000, with a minimum of two drives, decent RAM and whatever features could be crammed in.

To research the various models and bundles available, I did a strictly Internet fact finding tour of the big manufacturers: Compaq, Dell, Gateway, Hewlett Packard ( HP ) and IBM. To the mix I wanted to spec out a “white box” or clone system that could be had from local computer consultants, who specialize in getting small businesses equipped. After deciding on a $3000 Canadian budget, and recognizing this would be without monitor or operating system, I set out to see what value would befall me. Everyone except HP let me take a base server and add or change components to reach my desired budget; on the HP site I selected a model and then added the price of listed options. All the players listed server hardware without operating system, since it would scare away most buyers. As well the proliferation of Linux as a free alternative allows for companies to focus the entire budget on hardware. Let’s take a look at the chart below and compare.

  Compaq Dell Gateway
Specifications ML330 2500SC 7400
Processor Intel P3 933 MHz Intel P3 933 MHz Intel P3 933 MHz
# Processors / Capacity 1 / 1 1 / 2 1 / 2
Chipset ServerWorks III SLC ServerWorks HE-SL RCC Champion LE 3
PCI: 64 bit / 32 bit / 66 MHz 2 / 4 / 0 3 / 2 / 2  2 / 5 / 0
RAM 128 MB ECC PC133 256 MB ECC PC133 256 MB ECC PC133
RAM Slots / Maximum 4 / 2 GB 6 / 4 GB 4 / 2 GB
1st Hard Drive 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 7200
2nd Hard Drive 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 18 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k
Hot Plug Bays: 1" / 1.6"  - 6 / 0 6 / 4
CD-ROM 40X ATAPI 24X ATAPI 48X ATAPI
Video 4 MB ATI Rage XL 8 MB ATI Rage XL 4 MB ATI Rage XL
Tape  -  -  -
Case 4U Tower 5U Tower* 5U Tower*
Bays: Internal / External 2 / 5 0 / 3 1 / 5
Power Supply: Watts / Fans 250 / 1 Redundant 3 x 300 / 4 Redundant 2 x 350 / ??
SCSI Controller Not Listed AIC 7899 LSI 53C1010
SCSI Type Single Wide Ultra2 Dual Wide Ultra3 Dual Wide Ultra3
SCSI Connections 1 ( 15 drives ) 2 ( 30 drives ) 2 ( 30 drives )
RAID Controller  -  -  -
ATA Controller Onboard Onboard ATA33 onboard
ATA Connections 1 ( 2 drives ) 1 ( 2 drives ) 2 ( 4 drives )
LAN Adapter Compaq NC3163 10/100 Intel Pro/100+ Intel 82559 10/100
Data / Fax Modem Compaq 56k PCI Actiontech 56K PCI 56k
Parallel / Serial / USB 1 / 2 / 2 1 / 2 / 2 1 / 2 / 2
Floppy/Keyboard/Mouse Y / Y / Y Y / Y / Y Y / Y / Y
Server Software Compaq SmartStart Dell OpenManage HP Openview ManageX
  Insight Manager XE Dell Diagnostics Gateway ServerManager
 
Warranty 3 Year / 1 Year On Site 3 Year Next Day On Site 3 Year On site
Online Documentation User Manuals, Updates User Manuals, Updates User Manuals, Updates
Size: H / W / D (Inches) 16.8 / 7.5 / 20.0 18.4 / 10.5 / 24.5 17.4 / 8.6 / 28.8
Price (U.S. / Cdn) 2050 / 3235 2077 / 3080 2089 / 3300
  Hewlett Packard IBM White Box
Specifications Netserver e800 xSeries 220 Custom Build
Processor Intel P3 933 MHz Intel P3 933 MHz Intel P3 933 MHz
# Processors / Capacity 1 / 2 1 / 2 2 / 2
Chipset RCC LE Serverworks ServerSet III LE Via Apollo Pro 133A
PCI: 64 bit / 32 bit / 66 MHz 2 / 5 3 / 2 / 0 0 / 5 / 0
RAM 128 MB ECC PC133 256 MB ECC PC133 1024 MB ECC PC133
RAM Slots / Maximum 4 / 2 GB 4 / 2 GB 4 / 2 GB
1st Hard Drive 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 9 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 40 GB ATA100 7200
2nd Hard Drive 18 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 18 GB Ultra3 SCSI 10k 3x 40 GB ATA100 7200
Hot Plug Bays: 1" / 1.6"  -  -  -
CD-ROM 40X ATAPI 48X ATAPI 16X DVD ATAPI
Video 4 MB Integrated 8 MB S3 Savage4 LT 4 MB ATI Rage XL
Tape  -  -  -
Case Tower 4U Tower* Tower
Bays: Internal / External 3 / 4 3 / 4 4 / 6
Power Supply: Watts / Fans 300 / 1 330 / 3 400 / 4
SCSI Controller Symbios AHA-7892  -
SCSI Type Dual Wide Ultra3 Single Wide Ultra3  -
SCSI Connections 2 ( 30 drives ) 1 ( 15 drives )  -
RAID Controller  -  - Promise FastTrak100
ATA Controller Onboard ATA33 onboard ATA100 onboard
ATA Connections 2 ( 4 drives ) 1 ( 2 drives ) 2 ( 4 drives )
LAN Adapter Intel 82559 10/100 Intel 82559 10/100 2x Intel 82559 10/100
Data / Fax Modem  - 56k PCI Creative 56k PCI
Parallel / Serial / USB 1 / 2 / 2 1 / 2 / 2 1 / 2 / 4
Floppy/Keyboard/Mouse Y / Y / Y Y / Y / Y Y / Y / Y
Server Software HP Netserver Navigator IBM Director Intel LanDesk
  HP Toptools for Servers IBM ServerGuide  Server Manager
  HP Remote Assistant
Warranty 3 Year On Site 3 Year Parts / 1 Year On Site 1 Year
Online Documentation User Manuals, Updates Manuals, Updates Manuals, Updates
Size: H / W / D (Inches) 17 / 7.1 / 19.5 18.5 / 6.5 / 20.0 20.6 / 8.1 / 18.6
Price (U.S. / Cdn) 2040 / 3220 1976 / 3120 1970 / 3100

 

Page 2

SME Server Comparison
Help support eBabble!